Honda Elevate vs MG Astor Performance Showdown: Which is the Best Variant in Rs 12-15 Lakh Range?

When it comes to the thrill of driving, what are some of the best performance cars or top sports cars in India, and what makes them high-performance car models? Today, let’s compare Honda Elevate and MG Astor, and see how their variants fare in terms of performance.

In this article, we will share

• What a performance enthusiast should look for in a car
• Honda Elevate vs MG Astor – a comprehensive analysis of their variants, performance and features
• How to pick the right car for you

What a Performance Enthusiast Looks for in a Car

Here’s what to look for in a car as a performance enthusiast:

• Acceleration and Speed – How quickly a car accelerates, what is its top speed
• Power – How it pulls weight, how is its high speed stability, does it feel strained while going up the hills, or with AC on
• Agility – How it behaves while turning at speeds
• Driving Experience/Handling – Is the gearbox smooth and responsive, how is its steering/braking performance

Performance enthusiasts prioritize driving dynamics and power when choosing a car. They seek vehicles with responsive engines, smooth power delivery, and minimal turbo lag. Agile handling, precise steering, and stable high-speed performance are crucial. 

Other desirable features include advanced transmissions, sporty suspensions that minimize body roll, and effective braking systems. Enthusiasts also appreciate engaging engine notes and well-designed ergonomics that enhance the driving experience.

Why Honda Elevate and MG Astor are Popular

The Honda Elevate and MG Astor have gained popularity among performance enthusiasts for their impressive driving dynamics and well-rounded packages. Both cars offer responsive engines with linear power delivery, ensuring an engaging driving experience. 

The Elevate’s advanced CVT transmission and the Astor’s smooth manual gearbox cater to different preferences. These vehicles also excel in handling, with minimal body roll and precise steering, allowing enthusiasts to confidently tackle twisty roads. 

The Elevate and Astor provide a comfortable yet sporty ride quality, striking a balance between performance and daily usability. Additionally, their modern designs, feature-rich interiors, and advanced safety systems make them attractive options for enthusiasts seeking a complete package.

Honda Elevate and MG Astor Variants Shortlist in Rs 12-15 Lakh Range

For Honda Elevate, we have:

Variant	Price as on 4 April 2024
V CVT	₹1,341,000
VX	₹1,370,000

For MG Astor, we have:

Variant	Price as on 4 April 2024
Select	₹1,298,000
Select CVT	₹1,398,000
Sharp Pro	₹1,441,000

Honda Elevate V CVT

This variant offers a good balance of performance and features. The advanced CVT transmission ensures smooth power delivery, while the 119.35 BHP engine provides ample power. The presence of traction control and electronic stability control (ESC) enhances stability and safety. If you’re looking for a family car, you can read our guide to the best Elevate variants for you.

Honda Elevate VX

With its manual transmission, the VX variant appeals to enthusiasts who prefer a more engaging driving experience. The 119.35 BHP engine and well-tuned suspension offer a sporty ride. The addition of alloy wheels adds to the visual appeal.

MG Astor Select

The Select variant delivers a responsive 108.49 BHP engine and a smooth manual transmission. The agile handling and minimal body roll make it enjoyable to drive. The glossy alloy wheels and LED headlights enhance its sporty appearance. We have also compared the Astor with Elevate for safety-conscious car buyers.

MG Astor Select CVT

For those preferring an automatic transmission, the Select CVT variant offers a convenient driving experience. The 108.49 BHP engine and CVT provide linear power delivery. The presence of ESC and hill hold assist adds to its capabilities.

MG Astor Sharp Pro

As the top-spec variant, the Sharp Pro offers the most comprehensive package. The 108.49 BHP engine and smooth manual transmission deliver engaging performance. The inclusion of features like a panoramic sunroof, synthetic leather upholstery, and a 10.1-inch touchscreen infotainment system adds to its premium appeal. If you are a gadget lover, you can read our comparison of the Astor with Kia Carens.

Our Pick for the Best Variant Among Honda Elevate and MG Astor for Performance Enthusiasts

After careful consideration, we recommend the Honda Elevate VX as the best variant for performance enthusiasts. This variant stands out for its impressive power output and excellent ride and handling characteristics. The 119.35 BHP engine in the Honda Elevate VX is significantly more powerful than the 108.49 BHP engine found in the MG Astor variants. This additional power allows for more thrilling acceleration and overall performance.

Moreover, the Honda Elevate VX offers a well-tuned suspension setup that strikes a perfect balance between sporty handling and a comfortable ride. The precise steering and minimal body roll instill confidence in the driver, especially when tackling twisty roads. The manual transmission in the VX variant adds to the engaging driving experience, allowing enthusiasts to have greater control over the car’s performance.

In terms of features, the Honda Elevate VX is well-equipped with essential safety and convenience features such as traction control, ESC, alloy wheels, and LED headlights. The presence of these features enhances the overall driving experience without compromising on the performance-oriented nature of the variant.

Overall, the Honda Elevate VX’s combination of superior power output, excellent ride and handling characteristics, and a well-rounded feature set make it the top choice for performance enthusiasts among the compared variants.

The Top 3 Choices

1. Honda Elevate VX
2. Honda Elevate V CVT
3. MG Astor Sharp Pro

Attributes	Honda Elevate VX	Honda Elevate V CVT	MG Astor Sharp Pro
Engine – Power (BHP)	119.35	119.35	108.49
Traction Control	Yes	Yes	Yes
ESC	Yes	Yes	Yes
Alloy Wheels	Yes	Steel	Yes
LED Headlights	Yes	Yes	Yes
Hill Hold Assist	Yes	Yes	Yes
Touchscreen Navigation	Yes	Yes	Yes
Voice Activated Controls	Yes	Yes	Yes
Android Auto/Apple CarPlay	Yes	Yes	Yes

How to Pick the Right Car for You

• The Honda Elevate VX secures the top spot for its superior power output and excellent ride and handling. The manual transmission adds to the engaging driving experience. 
• The Honda Elevate V CVT follows closely, offering the same powerful engine but with a smooth CVT transmission for added convenience.
• The MG Astor Sharp Pro takes the third position, providing a feature-rich package and a responsive 108.49 BHP engine. While it may not match the power output of the Honda Elevate variants, it still offers an enjoyable driving experience.

These variants prioritize power, ride and handling, and a well-rounded feature set to deliver an exhilarating driving experience.

If you’re interested in reading more such face-to-face comparisons of popular car variants, head over to our Buying Advice section.